"What shall I do with you, O Ephraim?
What shall I do with you, O Judah?
Your love is like a morning cloud,
like the dew that goes away early.
Therefore I have hewn them by the prophets;
I have killed them by the words of my mouth,
and my judgment goes forth as the light.
For I desire steadfast love and not sacrifice,
the knowledge of God rather than burnt offerings." (Hosea 6:4-6)
What a startling thing it is for God to sing the blues. It would seem that God, of all beings in the universe, should not ever have to be disappointed, disillusioned, or brokenhearted--and yet, these verses from the book of the prophet Hosea surely sound like God is lamenting over the fickle, faithless, and flighty "love" the people have shown. It sure does sound like God has the blues.
And what a grievance it is. Like the best of blues singers, the prophet puts some zingers in the lyrics that God is singing. God looks at the people and their shaky track record of abandoning God when some new attraction comes along, and says, "Your love is like a morning cloud... like the dew that goes away early." That's a stinging criticism, especially as a contrast to the words we heard in yesterday's devotion that come just prior to this passage, where God's love is described as being as sure as the rising us and as reliably refreshing as the spring rains. God is faithful and can be counted on--but the people (ahem, which includes US) are erratic and inconstant. God's love is steady and sure, but the people's love seems to evaporate like the dewdrops in the summer sun. And God's lament--God's song of the blues, so to speak--is that God has been faithful to them all this time, while they have turned away to every sort of distraction and all kinds of other objects of their affection.
When they get called out on it, the people's go-to response is to just try and butter God up and bribe God with sacrifices. It became almost a transactional kind of thinking: "Every time we've cheated on God with the idols of our neighbors, we can win God back with a few goats and bulls on the altar." For all the times the people collectively hardened their hearts toward God and one another, they thought they could make up for it with some hastily offered sacrifices. Like the serial adulterer who tries to woo back the jilted spouse with some sparkling earrings, the people seemed to think that their ritual actions could make up for their wandering hearts. And God, the One who had been cheated on, just finally up and says, "No. You can't buy me off." Sounds like the plot of a standard blues song, if you ask me.
I think of that 90s hair-band acoustic ballad, "More Than Words" by the band Extreme, which made a similar point. Signing to the beloved who is full of nice "talk" but doesn't seem to act in ways that show love, the song's refrain goes, "More than words is all I ever needed you to show/ Then you wouldn't have to say that you love me/ 'Cause I'd already know." God sings it much the same here in these words from Hosea: God basically comes down to saying, "What I have really wanted all along wasn't some ritual sacrifice--what I really want is for you to show genuine love."
Now, as you might also recall if you heard these words this past Sunday alongside the passage in Matthew's Gospel where he quotes this passage to the Respectable Religious Leaders, Jesus seems to widen the direction that love. When the Respectable Religious Leaders are upset that Jesus welcomes "tax collectors and sinners" to his table with unconditional love, Jesus responds, "Go and learn what this means: 'I desire mercy, not sacrifice'." In other words, Jesus makes it clear that what God has always wanted is love--not just toward God, but toward other people. God was never impressed with our ritual precision or the exclusivity of our social circles, but God has always wanted us to be merciful to one another--especially the people we were ready to write off or leave out. That's what the God who has always loved us faithfully would want: simply for the love to continue onward through us with the same constancy and faithfulness as it has first been shown to us. No diamond tennis bracelets or gold rings, no goats or bulls burned up on the altar, no big checks with lots of zeroes, and no big stone monuments to show our piety--just love for the unloved, mercy for the ones who need it, and compassion for the neighbors around us. That's the antidote to God's brokenhearted blues.
Something changes in our relationship with God and with other people when we stop thinking we have to bribe God to ignore our wayward actions and infidelities. We no longer see our relationship with God as a monetary transaction, and we can give up the attempt to bribe the almighty (who doesn't need anything we could offer or buy in the first place!). And we can see other people as the channels through which we can show love to God. God doesn't need food--but our hungry neighbors do, and God would love it if they could eat. God doesn't need a roof over the divine head--but refugees fleeing war zones and folks without homes do, and God would be delighted if we provided them shelter. Instead of thinking we need to periodically "pay God off" so that we are then free to be crooked jerks to each other, the prophet invites us to see the people around us as the means through which we can offer love to God, which is what God has been after all along.
Today is the day, then, to add a new verse to the song, a turn after the blues have been sung, when our hearts are finally reoriented back to loving God by loving the people around us. After all the foolish and futile things we've done to impress God or buy God off when those never needed to be done in the first place, we can finally let our lives say back to God, "I love you, too."
Lord God, you who have been faithful and compassionate to us all our lives, we love you too.






