How To Resist Evil (Without Resorting to Evil)--August 3, 2026
"Now when Jesus heard [about the beheading of John the Baptizer,] he withdrew from there in a boat to a deserted place by himself. But when the crowds heard it, they followed him on foot from the towns. When he went ashore, he saw a great crowd, and he had compassion for them and cured their sick." (Matthew 14:13-14)
As many times as I have heard this passage and read this story (as we did this past Sunday in worship), I don't think it ever registered with me that the miracle we call the Feeding of the Five Thousand begins, at least in Matthew's telling, with the looming shadow of state violence against Jesus' forerunner, John. What a set up for a story of miraculous abundance! What a dark and foreboding introduction to the scene, you know?
The way these verses frame the story is important. They remind us that the Powers of the Day are always looking to snuff out any spark of criticism and to stomp out any resistance to their rule. John the Baptizer had landed himself into trouble with the Roman puppet-king Herod for criticizing the fact that Herod took his brother's wife for himself. That prophetic stance speaking truth to power cost John his head, and when news of John's violent demise reached Jesus, he was of course distraught. Of course, part of the heaviness of the moment was pure grief: even though Matthew's version of the story only has John and Jesus interact a handful of times, Luke tells us that they are cousins, and presumably they would have grown up knowing one another. So taking that into consideration, part of Jesus' need to withdraw is surely just his own personal mourning over a relative.
But there's more to it than that, as well. John didn't just pass away quietly and peacefully from a long illness after a full and well-lived life, after all. He was murdered by a jealous ruler who wanted him silenced--his death is a travesty of justice, and at least at the present moment, it looks like Herod is going to get away with it. Like so many despotic governments in history, the Herod dynasty (going back to Herod "the Great") has no trouble at all with disappearing people who speak up against their rule, and that is a terrible truth to have to bear. Jesus isn't only grieving for his cousin, friend, and fellow prophet--he is surely also grieving what it says about their society that Herod and his ilk can act with impunity like that.
And of course, Jesus also knows that what happens to John is surely a foretaste of what is in store for him. Jesus, after all, will take up the very same message that John had announced in his ministry: "The Reign of God has come near! Turn around and be a part of it!" If John was truly a prophet sent by God and he was not spared such a gruesome fate, then Jesus cannot expect to be spared the same, or similar, fate. If it were not clear already for Jesus, this certainly removes any doubt that there is a cross in store for him. And so it is certainly understandable that Jesus would need to step back, regroup, and respond to what has happened to John.
Surely some of his friends and disciples would have advised him to just lay low for a while, maybe to hide out away from the public until the heat was off. Others might have told him, "Maybe if John just wouldn't have gotten so political, things would have been different." Maybe some in Jesus' circles would have just advised him to give up on being a public figure at all and to go back to working with his hands like Joseph had. Jesus has to take a beat here to consider what is the right way to respond to the situation. There were certainly several options: retreat and stop speaking up against the likes of Herod? Raise up a militia to launch a coup and try to kill Herod out of vengeance and then crown himself king in his place? Hide forever? React in outrage and violence? Run away somewhere safe on the one hand, or incite a riot in protest on the other? How do you resist the powers of evil when they are clearly willing to employ cruel and brutal tactics like beheading John?
And maybe even more importantly, how do you resist those powers without giving into their tactics and resorting to evil yourself?
That's the hardest part of this situation, I'm sure. It would be easy if we were in Jesus' sandals to justify lashing back out in violence against Herod and his cronies--to kill one of Herod's soldiers, or to launch an assault on someone in the royal family. It would have been tempting to think, "Why not try to get rid of Herod himself and replace him? I am a the TRUE King of the Jews, after all--I could just move things along a little faster and take the crown for myself now!" It would certainly have been easy to let raw emotion provoke a reaction without any forethought or consideration of consequences and to mount a violent attack to try and get revenge. Or, had Jesus been in a more cynical mood, he could have just given up all together and decided there was no use in resisting evil at all, and just to let Herod's violence and cruelty go unaddressed. Maybe he could have even tried to join the ranks of Herod's loyal subjects--after all, if you can't beat 'em, join 'em, right?
Jesus, of course, does no such thing. He neither gives in to the despairing thought that evil cannot be resisted, nor does he surrender to the impulse to answer violence and cruelty with some of his own. Jesus takes a moment to grieve, and then he responds to Herod's evil... with good. The crowds, who are also harassed and troubled by Herod, come to seek Jesus out--and instead of withdrawing further, Jesus has compassion on them. He heals their sicknesses, and he gives them his time. He answers the brutality of Herod with gentleness and help for those who are suffering. He doesn't merely curse the darkness; Jesus offers light in the midst of it.
This is the calling Jesus gives to all who are a part of his movement, too: we are called to answer the rottenness so often on display in the world with decency, to respond to evil with good, and to meet cruelty with compassion. For every act of intimidation and domination the Herods attempt, Jesus and his followers will respond with fearless love and public mercy. Every time they try to disappear someone as they did to John, Jesus' community will be a witness and will pick up the baton. We will resist evil without playing evil's game by its rules, by showing up in the world with compassion and healing. We will, as Paul the apostle would put it to the Romans, "overcome evil with good."
Jesus was showing us how to do just that all along--it is his own way in the world, and it always has been.
Lord Jesus, prepare us to face the rottenness in the world with your kind of life-giving goodness.






