You Give Them Something--August 4, 2026
When it was evening, the disciples came to him and said, “This is a deserted place, and the hour is now late; send the crowds away so that they may go into the villages and buy food for themselves.” Jesus said to them, “They need not go away; you give them something to eat.” They replied, “We have nothing here but five loaves and two fish.” And he said, “Bring them here to me.” (Matthew 14:15-18)
Jesus' disciples don't mean to be rude--they think they are being realistic.
As this scene unfolds from the passage many of us heard in worship this past Sunday, it's clear that Jesus' disciples simply think there's nothing else to be done but to dismiss the crowds who have been listening to Jesus so they can get home and get their own suppers. This is not a matter of hospitality to them, but of crowd control. Jesus had gone off by himself first, you will recall, and it was the crowds that came out to him seeking his help. So this was not a matter of Jesus having invited a big gathering for an all-day teaching workshop and then not having thought through how to provide a meal for the attendees. This was more like Jesus had tried to go on personal retreat, was hounded by people who wanted his help, and then decided he would not only cure their sicknesses but also would feed them. The disciples aren't trying to be rude or bad hosts: they just realize that they are not in a position to do anything to solve the problem of feeding a crowd of thousands.
And in fairness to the disciples, too, the dinner question is not a matter of life and death. Sure, people get cranky when they are hungry or if their blood sugar drops too low, but delaying an evening meal by having to walk all the way home to eat still seems pretty manageable for most people. As far as the disciples are concerned, the most compassionate thing Jesus can do right now is just to send the people away so they can all fend for themselves. After all, he didn't promise a free supper, so no harm, no foul. The disciples are just trying to be as politely practical as possible when they advise Jesus to dismiss everybody for the night.
Jesus' response to these level-headed disciples is what changes everything. "You give them something to eat," he says, almost as if he believes it is the most obvious thing in the world. But the disciples cannot reasonably be expected to have planned for something like this, can they? When they got up that morning, not a one of them had even an inkling that Jesus would wander off into the middle of nowhere, be tracked down by thousands of people who would then want to hang around with Jesus until sundown. And certainly none of them imagined that such a large crowd would come unprepared for bringing their own suppers. But Jesus just looks at them and says, "You feed them." Not because the disciples "owe" it to anybody, but because that is the nature of the Reign of God.
That's it, I believe. Jesus' first impulse in view of the hungry crowds is that he and his followers should feed them all, not because there is some rule of social expectation that says they must, or because they have some transactional requirement, but because that is what God is like. In the kingdom of God, everybody gets to eat. Throughout the Bible, God's character, from the manna in the wilderness to the story of Elijah and the jar of meal that provided the widow with food through the famine, to the prophets' repeated calls for the people to share their bread with the hungry poor, has always been oriented toward making sure everybody gets enough to eat. Jesus has come to embody the God of the Scriptures--to show us in his words, actions, and presence, what it is like where God reigns. So it makes perfect sense that Jesus directs his disciples to feed the multitudes, because they are meant to be learning how to participate in God's reign, too. They are being formed to act, speak, and think in ways that reflect God's character, by being in Jesus' presence. When Jesus says to the disciples, "You give them something to eat," it is his way of bringing them into the work that God is doing in Jesus.
Now, as those of us who have heard this story before already know, Jesus will bring something to the situation that is beyond the power of his disciples on their own. By Jesus' power, at the breaking and blessing and sharing of the loaves, there will be enough not only to feed the thousands there, but twelve baskets full of leftovers, as well. But the disciples are a part of this moment, too. Jesus invites them to share in this moment and to be agents through whom God feeds hungry people, just because that is the sort of thing on God's heart. This isn't a "You have to do this if you want to get full credit for taking my class" sort of moment; it is, rather, "You are being pulled into God's action in the world, and I want you to get to share in it." It's not a "have to" sort of thing, so much as a "get to" kind of experience.
This is what Jesus is constantly doing with his disciples as he empowers them to share in his work, which is always the work of revealing God's Kingdom (or, if you like, the work of unveiling the policy priorities of the Yahweh Administration). Jesus heals people, yes, and he also sends his disciples out to heal others. Jesus welcomes outcasts to his table, and then dares his disciples to extend their tables as well. Jesus lifts up the lowly, and he trains his disciples to do the same. And he does all of those things, not as a prerequisite for achieving or earning a spot on his team, but because the whole point for them has been to experience God's Reign more fully. Jesus didn't call disciples merely to be a traveling audience to watch him perform amazing stunts; he called them to share in the work that flows from the character of God. Disciples learn to feed people because Jesus is about the business of feeding people--and Jesus cares about feeding people because that is the very heart of God. Jesus is not only teaching us "This is what God's Reign is like," but shaping us to participate in what God's Reign is like ourselves. That's what we're here for.
So when I hear folks wonder why it is worth it for a congregation out in the comfortable and well-fed suburbs to support and volunteer at a weekly meal hosted by fellow disciples in a particularly impoverished neighborhood of the city, I think of Jesus' response to his disciples. When I hear church folks in the United States ask why we bother to raise money or send supplies to folks rebuilding after disasters or wars in far-flung places all over the world, I think of Jesus' invitation to his followers. Helping to make sure everybody gets to eat isn't just "someone else's job", but rather it is part of God's work in the world, because it is God's own priority in the Kingdom that everybody gets to eat. Jesus turns to us still, like he did to Peter, James, John and the rest of the group frozen with that deer-in-the-headlights look on their eyes, and he says once again to us, "You give them something to eat," precisely because that is what God cares about. Giving people daily bread, just because they exist, is one of the top policy priorities of the Yahweh Administration--Jesus is just trying to let us be a part of what God is already doing in the world, rather than us missing out.
Will we take up the invitation Jesus has given to us? Will we let ourselves be pulled into the work God is already committed to in the world? And will we allow ourselves to be more fully alive knowing that we got to be a part of the revealing of God's Reign as we help to pass out the broken bread Jesus puts into our hands so that we might share it with the next person... until everybody gets to eat? That sounds like a day... or a life... well-spent.
Lord Jesus, place daily bread in our hands that we might share it with the neighbors around us who are hungry, too.






