Thursday, June 14, 2018

Diagnosis, Not Verdict

Diagnosis, Not Verdict--June 14, 2018


"Whoever says, 'I am in the light,' while hating a brother or sister is still in the darkness.  Whoever loves a brother or sister lives in the light, and in such a person there is no cause for stumbling.  But whoever hates another believer is in the darkness, walks in the darkness, and does not know the way to go, because the darkness has brought blindness." [1 John 2:9-11]
My grandfather used to say, "Walk like you're going somewhere."  As that little proverb was interpreted to me over the years, his point was always quite literally about walking--as in, when you are walking, you should be efficient, purposeful, focused, at a pace that gets you to your destination.  My grandfather was not a saunterer, and would not have looked kindly on moseying.  The walk-like-you're-going-somewhere philosophy of travel was always about being purposeful and intentional: the point of walking was to get where you were going.  He was not a competitive runner or racer--so the efficiency business was never about trying to be faster than someone else or to win a prize.  It was more about focus--if you're going to walk, walk, and go where you're going, I think he would have said.
The first Christians kept coming back to the picture of their lives as a walk.  "Christ was raised from the dead," Paul said to the Romans, "so that we might walk in newness of life."  And in fact, throughout the New Testament a good number of Bible translations will just put the word "live" where the original Greek uses the verb "walk," because the metaphor of walking=living was so well-worn for the early church.  And here in 1 John, we get more of this walking business, too.  John talks about the how and the where of walking (i.e., living), and whether we are walking "in the light" or "in the darkness."
But why does he ask?  What's the interest underneath the question?  Given the culture in which we live--a vote-the-loser-off-the-island way of seeing the world--we might think John is interested in dividing up the world, or the church, into piles for final judgment.  There are the "in the light" people, who are clearly heaven-bound, we would venture.  And there are the "in the darkness" people, who are not so lucky--is that about right?  We are tempted to hear this "in the darkness" and "in the light" business as the issuing of a final verdict, a description of who are the winners and who are the losers in some kind of salvation race.
But that's not really the way John talks here.  He doesn't seem to be giving final verdicts so much as giving present-moment diagnoses.  And the point of a diagnosis, as opposed to an autopsy, of course, is to offer a course of action to remedy what is sick or diseased.  John is interested in getting his readers to "walk like they are going somewhere," which is to say, to be mindful and purposeful in the ways they live.  He is not interested in refereeing a race or holding time trials--in other words, this is not about competition or comparison between people (who's a better Christian than whom?  Who's a true Christian compared to whom?  That sort of thing), but about getting people who are limping and stumbling along to walk rightly, the way they were intended to all along.  John describes what it looks like to walk in the darkness and to walk in the light, not so that we can label our friends or co-workers or fellow church members once and for all as "good eggs" and "bad eggs," but rather so that we can all be corrected when we are off the path or have lost the right pace or have started to limp.
In other words, when we find someone else is "walking in darkness"--which John equates with refusal to love--there is every hope that he or she can be brought back "into the light"--that is, back into the practice of Christ-like love.  And at the very same time, when someone else helps me to see that I have been "walking in darkness" and refusing to love the people put into my life, there is every hope that I will be brought back to walking rightly again.  When I'm no longer "walking like I'm going somewhere," I need those other voices to get my pace back in step with the one I am following.  When I fall away from loving the community of believers that God has placed in my life, I will depend on that community to help pull me back--to retrain my feet, you could say, and to learn to stop tripping over myself.
It would be so easy for us to start labeling people as beyond hope--as irredeemably "walking in darkness"--or to get comfortably complacent with ourselves and insist that we are "walking in the light" and therefore don't need others to help keep us in the way of Jesus.  But John insists that we are always on the move--always in motion following Jesus, and that will mean there is always the opportunity to be led back into love and out of "darkness" along the way.  Today, we have the opportunity to walk like we are going somewhere by practicing real love for the real people who cross our paths today.
Lord Jesus, keep us walking in the light, and keep us gracious as we seek to keep one another walking after you, too, while we entrust ourselves to their guidance, too.

No comments:

Post a Comment